NPA Vancouver’s George Affleck calls for review of the City’s Granville Entertainment District policies

The NPA reaffirms its commitment to bring forward and support policies and strategies that shape and deliver vibrant public spaces in the downtown and across every neighbourhood in the city.

February 15, 2018, Vancouver, B.C. – NPA Vancouver City Councillor George Affleck is calling for a review of the City’s policies relating to the Granville Entertainment District. At next week’s City Council meeting, Affleck will introduce a motion asking for staff to assess the effectiveness of the City’s existing policies in reducing street disorder, reducing gender-based violence, and improving business in the Granville Entertainment District.

Affleck’s motion echoes a previous motion he brought forward 4-1/2 years ago in July 2013 entitled “Review and Enhancement of Granville Entertainment District” and it follows the recent death of Kalwinder Thind who was fatally stabbed outside a downtown nightclub at the end of January.

“Four and half years ago I brought forward a motion calling for consultation with the Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association, and other stakeholders, and an update on the Granville Entertainment District. My intent was to have Council address the issues we continue to see in this area of the downtown,” said Affleck. “The Vision majority on Council sidelined my Granville Entertainment District motion in 2013, and now, four and a half years later, we’re no further ahead than we were back then. It’s very discouraging and unacceptable that nothing has changed.”

The minutes of the July 9, 2013, Council meeting indicate that Affleck’s 2013 motion was referred to staff with direction to prepare a memorandum for Council reviewing the process by which a design team was selected to create the “$21-million, national award-winning Granville Entertainment District.” The referral motion also specified that the memorandum should include information relating to the cost of construction and any feedback received from stakeholders regarding the redesigned street.

The referral of Affleck’s motion in 2013 was moved by Vision Councillor Heather Deal and seconded by Vision Councillor Louie.

NPA Vancouver Councillors George Affleck and Elizabeth Ball, and Green Party Councillor Adriane Carr, all voted against Councillor Deal’s referral motion.

In addition to calling for a review of current City policies relating to the Granville Entertainment District, including recommendations relating to the parking and transit situation on the street, and options for enhancing the dining and live music experience on the street, Affleck’s new motion calls for Council:

  • to direct staff to work with the Vancouver Police Department, Bar Watch, and other relevant stakeholders to determine the viability, budget, and timeframe for reactivation of the Street Surveillance Camera Network
  • to call on the Provincial Government to join the City of Vancouver, relevant stakeholders, and the transportation industry (i.e., taxi, limousine, transit) to develop a targeted strategy to provide better transportation services unique to the Granville Entertainment District – a high need area of the city
  • to direct staff to review the possibility of allowing later hours for the Granville Entertainment District to smooth out closing times of various establishments rather than requiring entertainment district businesses to adhere to policies which unnecessarily, and adversely, affect these businesses and in turn unnecessarily, and adversely, affect Vancouver’s reputation as a robust tourism and hospitality destination
  • to direct staff to consult with the BC Entertainment Hall of Fame (which has invested over $300,000 for bronze plaques up and down Granville Street), Entertainment Producers, Vancouver Civic Theatres (such as the Orpheum which fronts onto Granville Street), and the City Archives regarding the issues evident in the Granville Entertainment District and to include these stakeholders in all future matters and consultations pertaining to the Granville Entertainment District.

The City of Vancouver’s stated strategy for the city’s downtown is “to shape and deliver vibrant public spaces.” The City’s website further states that Vancouver’s public spaces – our plazas, squares, streets, laneways, pathways, and waterfront – are where people connect with the city, and with each other; where public life happens and community is created.

The NPA is firmly committed to bringing forward, and supporting, policies and strategies that shape and deliver vibrant public spaces in the downtown and in every neighbourhood across the city.

A preview of the text of Councillor Affleck’s motion is appended at the end of this media release.

-30-

For more information please email media@npavancouver.ca

MOTION – Upgrading, Reviewing and Revising the Granville Entertainment District

MOVER: Councillor Affleck
SECONDER: Councillor Bremner

WHEREAS

1. Vancouver’s public spaces – our plazas, squares, streets, laneways, pathways, and waterfront – are where public life happens and where community is created – spaces where we connect with the city and with each other;

2. “Places for People Downtown” seeks to create a strategy to shape and deliver vibrant public spaces in downtown Vancouver;

3. At the Tuesday, July 9, 2013 Regular Council Meeting, Councillor George Affleck introduced a motion entitled “Review and Enhancement of Granville Entertainment District”;

4. Councillor Affleck’s motion called for City staff to consult with the Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and other pertinent stakeholders to provide an update on the Granville Entertainment District with a view to:

  • Reviewing the parking situation on the street;
  • Providing options for enhancing the dining experience on the street, including allowing greater use of the street for outdoor dining by neighboring food establishments;
  • Reviewing other potential upgrades and opportunities for the area

5. Councillor Affleck’s July 9, 2013 motion was referred to staff with direction to provide a memorandum to Council reviewing the process used to select a design team to create the $21-million, national award-winning Granville Entertainment District, the cost of construction and any feedback received from stakeholders regarding the redesigned street (referral moved by Councillor Deal; seconded by Councillor Louie – opposed by Councillors Affleck, Ball, and Carr);

6. A records search conducted by City staff for the memorandum to Council noted above in WHEREAS clause No. 3 failed to locate any follow up memorandum to Council reviewing the process used to select a design team to create the $21-million, national award-winning Granville Entertainment District, the cost of construction, or any feedback received from stakeholders regarding the redesigned street;

7. At the Wednesday, June 14, 2017, meeting of the Standing Committee of Council on City Finance and Services, City staff presented Liquor Policy Review recommendations to Council, including a recommendation to adopt and implement adjustments for the Granville Street/Granville Entertainment District “to reduce problems”;

8. The City Finance and Services Committee heard from four speakers at the Wednesday, June 14, 2017, meeting in support of the report and 16 speakers who were either in opposition or expressed concerns regarding specific aspects of the report;

9. Councillor Carr offered an amendment at the June 14, 2017 committee meeting whereby the recommendations referencing the Granville Entertainment District and the Downtown Eastside in recommendations E.19, and I.27, on pages 13 to 14 of the Policy Report dated June 7, 2017, entitled “Liquor Policy Review – Recommended Actions”, be removed, and be referred to a working group of key stakeholders noted elsewhere in the staff recommendations;

10. Vote No. 02024 records that Councillors Deal, Jang, Louie, Meggs, Reimer, Stevenson and Mayor Robertson opposed Councillor Carr’s June 14, 2017 amendment relating to the Granville Entertainment District and the Downtown Eastside and the amendment did not carry;

11. A recommendation, contained in the staff report presented to Council on June 14, 2017 (i.e., “Liquor Policy Review – Recommended Actions”), to direct City staff to establish a working group of key stakeholders in the Granville Entertainment District, including local bars and restaurants, Bar Watch, the Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association, Vancouver Police Department, Vancouver Coastal Health and community organizations, including women’s organizations, to improve consultation and co-ordination of efforts to reduce street disorder and gender-based violence, and to improve business in the area carried unanimously (Vote No. 02027);

12. Events of recent days underscore the fact that violent crime continues to be a persistent issue on Granville Street and it is time to change how the Granville Entertainment District operates to make it a safer place for people late at night.

THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED

A. THAT Vancouver City Council direct staff to review current City policies relating to the Granville Entertainment District to assess the effectiveness of these policies in reducing street disorder, reducing gender-based violence, and improving business in the area, and provide recommendations relating to (but not limited to):

  • A review of the parking and transit situation on the street;
  • Options for enhancing the dining and live music experience on the street, including allowing greater use of the street for outdoor patio dining by neighboring food establishments
  • A review of other potential upgrades and opportunities for the area

B. THAT Vancouver City Council direct staff to work with the Vancouver Police Department, Bar Watch, and other relevant stakeholders to determine the viability, budget, and timeframe for reactivation of the Street Surveillance Camera Network; and

C. THAT the City of Vancouver call on the Provincial Government to join the City of Vancouver, relevant stakeholders, and the transportation industry (i.e., taxi, limousine, transit) to develop a targeted strategy to provide better transportation services unique to the Granville Entertainment District as a high need area of the city; and

D. THAT Vancouver City Council direct staff to review the possibility of allowing later hours for the Granville Entertainment District to smooth out closing times of various establishments rather than requiring entertainment district businesses to adhere to policies which unnecessarily, and adversely, affect these businesses and in turn unnecessarily, and adversely, affect Vancouver’s reputation as a robust tourism and hospitality destination; and

E. THAT Vancouver City Council direct staff to consult with the BC Entertainment Hall of Fame (which has invested over $300,000 for bronze plaques up and down Granville Street), Entertainment Producers, Vancouver Civic Theatres (such as the Orpheum which fronts onto Granville Street), and the City Archives regarding the manifest issues evident in the Granville Entertainment District and to include these stakeholders in all future matters and consultations pertaining to the Granville Entertainment District.

 

*  *  *  *  *

 

 

 

 

 

 

NPA School Trustees call on Minister of Education to end the dysfunction at the VSB

Delaying tactics and public criticism of the work of senior VSB staff by some trustees has made Board meetings and planning sessions “an intolerable, toxic place to be”: NPA School Trustees

Vancouver, B.C., October 17, 2016 – The Vancouver Non-Partisan Association (NPA) School Trustees are calling on the Minister of Education to release a Special Advisor’s Report and take action to end the toxic dysfunction at the Vancouver School Board (VSB). The current School Board, they say, is “a Board of inaction” that has failed to create a positive, respectful work environment for the District’s senior staff.

The NPA School Trustees note that the Minister has granted several extensions to the latest Special Advisor assigned to investigate the VSB: “We want the Minister to act, and to act now. It’s time to release the Special Advisor’s Report and take action to end the dysfunction at the Vancouver School Board.”

Setting aside the recent allegations of bullying and harassment currently being investigated by WorkSafeBC, the NPA School Trustees point to several examples of VSB trustees who have publicly challenged the professional work and recommendations of senior staff, simply because the recommendations did not conform to the political agenda of those trustees. Examples include:

•         Trustees attempting to delay action on the District’s longstanding enrolment realities by demanding that the Board wait for new census data to arrive, even though the historical evidence cited by senior staff clearly indicates that this data is not an effective tool for projecting student enrolment. This year, the District’s enrolment planning tools predicted student enrolment with a 99.95% accuracy.

•         Trustees who have claimed that the consultations surrounding the school closure process were not robust enough, even though District staff went above and beyond in following the Board’s detailed School Closure Policy – a policy drafted and voted into effect by previous Vision-dominated boards.

•         Trustees demanding a report on population projections from the City when every trustee knows full well that District staff already meet regularly with the City’s planning staff in order to gather information about future developments that may impact on school enrollment: Staff already have this information factored into their recommendations.

•         Trustees who have publicly suggested that the removal of the 95% capacity requirement by the Ministry of Education has somehow changed everything despite correspondence the Board has received directly from the Ministry which states that the same school seismic approval process will be followed as before. The previous process did not rely on the 95% utilization target, and several Vancouver schools that were below 95% capacity were approved for seismic upgrading.

•         Trustees who want to revisit the District’s Long Range Facilities Plan planning process despite that fact that none of the underlying fundamentals have changed.

“As trustees who respect the sound advice and well-considered recommendations provided by our senior staff, we (the NPA School Trustees) have found the delaying tactics of other trustees, and the public criticism of the work of senior staff, very difficult to watch. It has made our Board meetings and planning sessions an intolerable, toxic place to be. The current Board is a Board of inaction. The Board has not taken any meaningful steps in the past two years to address the pressing financial and seismic issues before it. Nor has the Board made any significant progress on many of the recommendations from last year’s Special Advisors report.

“Senior staff have found themselves having to deal with the disparate interests of the Board’s nine elected Trustees while also trying to deal with the interests of – and direction from – senior officials at the Ministry of Education. This has put our senior staff in an untenable, unworkable position for which there are few if any easy solutions. The senior staff we have lost were the education experts whose expertise and experience is essential to the proper functioning of the school district and to meeting the Board’s basic mandate, which is to facilitate the effective teaching and learning of students. The time for the Minister to act is now, for the good of our staff and our students.”

ICYMI – Listen to Stacy Robertson on this morning’s Jon McComb Show on CKNW:

 

Statement from NPA School Trustee Stacy Robertson on Forensic Audit of VSB

Statement from NPA School Trustee Stacy Robertson on Forensic Audit of VSB:

STACY ROBERTSON - NPA SCHOOL TRUSTEEThis morning, the Minister of Education announced that a “forensic audit and full review of the Vancouver School Board (VSB) is being launched by the Ministry of Education in the wake of the board’s refusal last night to pass a balanced budget.”

As disappointed as my NPA School Trustee colleagues and I are that the board failed in its duty to pass a balanced budget, we are nevertheless encouraged by the swift and measured response by the Minister.

My NPA School Trustee colleagues – Fraser Ballantyne, Penny Noble, and Christopher Richardson – and I agree that students are, and need to remain, our first priority. Read more

NPA City Councillors Attend Community Led Rally in Support of Residents who Have had Enough

Vancouver, B.C., June 26, 2016 – NPA City Councillors George Affleck and Melissa De Genova, joined by Councillor Elizabeth Ball, attended a rally today in support of Vancouver residents who gathered at Kits Beach to protest Vision Vancouver’s lack of consultation and wasteful infrastructure spending. In particular, speakers spoke out against the wasteful use of taxpayers’ dollars to further upgrade Point Grey Road, as well as the $3.5 million to be spent on fencing for the Burrard Bridge; a plan rammed through by the Vision majority on City Council without any consultation whatsoever with the community. Read more

NPA City Councillor George Affleck responds to Information and Privacy Commissioner Elizabeth Denham’s damning report on the City of Vancouver’s FOI practices

Vancouver, B.C., June 23, 2016 – NPA City Councillor George Affleck is available today to comment on the report released this morning by B.C. Information and Privacy (OPIC) Commissioner Elizabeth Denham regarding the City of Vancouver’s FOI practices.

Commissioner Denham states in this morning’s OPIC news release: “… there is a need for change to the approach City staff use in processing access requests. We observed shortcomings in almost every step of the freedom of information process – from receipt of the request, to searching for records, to the timeliness of response to the applicant and the content of the response itself. This highlights the need for a move to a culture of transparency and service quality,” said Denham. Read more

NPA delivers on commitment to build new Marpole-Oakridge Community Centre at the existing Oak Park site at Oak Street & 59th Avenue

Motion brought forward by NPA Park Board Commissioner, and Park Board Chair, Sarah Kirby-Yung calls for public consultations to begin in 2016, design and planning in 2017, and ground breaking for new Marpole-Oakridge Community Centre in 2018.

Vancouver, B.C., June 14, 2016 – An NPA campaign commitment to build a new Marpole-Oakridge Community Centre took a big step forward at last night’s Park Board meeting thanks to a motion brought forward by NPA Park Board Commissioner, and Chair, Sarah Kirby-Yung. The motion, which carried unanimously, calls for the community centre to remain at the current Oak Park site at Oak Street & 59th Avenue. The motion also calls for the consultation and planning process to begin as soon as possible utilizing consultation funding already allocated in the 2016 Park Board budget. Read more

NPA School Trustee Stacy Robertson wants the City of Vancouver to step up and pay costs to operate Britannia Centre

Robertson says the VSB cannot afford to provide funding for a community centre outside its jurisdictional mandate when it is cutting literacy teachers, multicultural workers, and making a host of other program cuts that will directly affect student learning.

Vancouver, B.C., June 6, 2016 – With an historic $24 million budget shortfall still facing the Vancouver School Board (VSB), and unprecedented cuts to core teaching staff and services, NPA School Trustee Stacy Robertson says he wants the VSB to look at the Britannia Centre operating agreement with the City of Vancouver and implore the City to step up and properly fund the Centre’s many worthwhile community amenities rather than relying on a tight VSB budget for funding. Read more

NPA City Councillor George Affleck calls on City of Vancouver to re-examine unpopular plan to add fencing to the Burrard Bridge

Vancouver, B.C., May 24, 2016 – NPA City Councillor George Affleck is calling on the City of Vancouver to re-examine the unpopular plan to add fencing to the Burrard Bridge; an internationally recognized masterpiece of the Art Deco style and one of the most important and iconic heritage structures in the City of Vancouver.

Affleck wants City staff to re-examine the design options, including options that would be less visually intrusive and destructive to the heritage aesthetics of the bridge and views from the bridge, as well as re-examining the effectiveness of fencing as a suicide prevention measure within the broader context of suicide prevention and mental health strategies.

“The plan to add fencing to the Burrard Bridge was not presented to the public during the public consultation, and to me that’s a serious omission,” said Affleck. “Professional opinion is also mixed on the effectiveness of fencing as a suicide prevention measure, and I’d like to see a broader discussion of the various opinions.”

In his motion, Affleck notes that the City of Vancouver and its Council members place tremendous value on the city’s historically and culturally significant buildings, monuments, and other sites and structures.

Affleck also notes that many of the people who walk and cycle over the Burrard Bridge do so specifically to enjoy the spectacular views of Vancouver it offers. Creating an enjoyable walking environment, he says, is one of the City of Vancouver’s top priorities and an important part of the City’s effort to become the greenest city in the world by 2020.

For a copy of Affleck’s motion, please click here.

-30-

Media please email media@npavancouver.ca

Contact Us

Get in touch with us

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial